Advertisement

 
 

Senate Race Rankings

Hotline's Amy Walter and Quinn McCord assess which Senate seats are most likely to switch party control in November based on a number of factors, including organization, money, buzz and polling.

In our final analysis of the 2008 Senate battlefield, things still look pretty bleak for the GOP. Nevertheless, a few endangered incumbents have shown minor upticks in their polling over the last week, giving some Republicans hope that a complete bloodbath may yet be avoided. Even so, it still seems likely that Democrats will net 6-9 seats on Tuesday. One minor point of trivia: Although Elizabeth Dole seems to have been universally shunned by her state's editorial boards, Gordon Smith, Norm Coleman and -- to a lesser extent -- John Sununu have won the lion's share of newspaper endorsements in their states. Ironically, if any of them win by a razor-thin margin, they may have the media to thank.

Updated: Oct. 31, 2008 • House Rankings



Rank State Incumbent/Party Previous
 1 Virginia Open Seat (R) 1

Moderate Republicans should probably be glad that Jim Gilmore, not Tom Davis, was their nominee. In future statewide nominating contests, moderates might well say to conservatives, "We tried it your way the last few times and it didn't work."

 2 New Mexico Open Seat (R) 2

If Tom Udall wins by 15 points or more, and if the GOP loses all three U.S. House seats, it may indicate the end of New Mexico as a presidential battleground.

 3 Colorado Open Seat (R) 3

Republicans had better hope Bob Schaffer doesn't lose worse than the 57%-40% margin by which they lost the governor's race in 2006. They just can't afford to have recruitment problems in a state like Colorado, with Senate and gubernatorial races coming up in 2010.

 4 New Hampshire John Sununu (R) 4

Republicans insist John Sununu has pulled within striking distance of Jeanne Shaheen, which may be the case. But how does an incumbent win when he trails his challenger in every single poll?

 5 Alaska Ted Stevens (R) 8

Perhaps Alaska Republicans should adopt the motto that Louisiana Democrats chose when Edwin Edwards faced off against David Duke in the 1991 Louisiana Governor's race: "Vote for the crook -- It's important." By the way, it seems likely that about 30,000 absentee/early votes were cast before Ted Stevens' conviction was announced.

 6 North Carolina Elizabeth Dole (R) 6

The conventional wisdom is that Elizabeth Dole is in pretty bad shape electorally-speaking, even if the race technically remains within the margin of error. Even many Republicans believe she's a goner. Her "Godless" TV ad certainly falls into the "Hail Mary" category, and only time will tell if it gives her a bump or is simply the final nail in her coffin.

 7 Oregon Gordon Smith (R) 5

For one of the closest Senate races in the country, there hasn't been much public polling conducted here over the past month. But even in Gordon Smith's own poll, he's held to 45%, and he seems to be trailing slightly in most others. Given the sizeable victory that Barack Obama will probably win in this state, a Smith win would be something of a minor upset at this point.

 8 Minnesota Norm Coleman (R) 7

This race has been within the margin of error for a couple months now, though Norm Coleman seems now to be inching up towards the higher end of that range. Given Al Franken's baggage, and the number of mini-scandals Norm Coleman has had to endure this cycle, this is one of those races where it's amazing that either candidate could actually win.

 9 Georgia Saxby Chambliss (R) 9

We suspect that if Saxby Chambliss's camp were offered the choice of a guaranteed 12/2 runoff or a clear winner on 11/4, they'd choose the runoff. Not only would the African-American turnout be more problematic in December, but Republicans who had voted against Chambliss might be willing to come home to him, if it became clear that Democrats would soon be in complete control in Washington.

 10 Louisiana Mary Landrieu (D) 12

Given the dearth of consistent polling data, many pundits put this race to bed awhile ago, assuming there was no way any incumbent Democratic senator could lose in an environment such as this. In other parts of the country that would certainly be true, but Louisiana is one state that still seems to be trending Republican, and Mary Landrieu could be in for yet another squeaker.

 11 Mississippi Roger Wicker (R) 10

Roger Wicker seems a bit safer than his colleague to the east, Saxby Chambliss, but he too will have to contend with an increased black voter turnout, which will probably keep this race tight.

 12 Kentucky Mitch McConnell (R) 11

The polling here has been fairly consistent over the past week. Mitch McConnell is at 47% with Bruce Lunsford trailing by 2 to 5 points. This is the type of race where an incumbent could conceivably get toppled, but only if it's a truly huge wave year.

 13 Maine Susan Collins (R) 13

Susan Collins still seems headed for a win, and there are murmurings she might even surpass her 59%-41% margin of victory in 2002. Given the difference in the national environment in 2008 compared to that year, such a landslide would be quite an amazing accomplishment.

 14 Texas John Cornyn (R) 14

In a state this expensive, it's just tough for any Democrat to be competitive, save for self-funders or other top-tier recruits who can generate significant starter cash from day one.

 15 New Jersey Frank Lautenberg (D) 18

An uphill state for any Republican in any year. With a late start, Dick Zimmer just never was able to raise the cash and develop the name ID he needed to compete.

 16 Idaho Open Seat (R) 16

Larry LaRocco has run a game campaign, but this is still Idaho.

 17 Oklahoma James Inhofe (R) 15

Other GOP senators should have learned a lesson from Jim Inhofe this cycle. Just because "the experts" are saying you have a safe seat, it doesn't mean you should refrain from pummeling your opponent into the ground before he has a chance to take off.

 18 Nebraska Open Seat (R) 17

Mike Johanns was one of the few Senate candidates this cycle who was never really hurt by his party label, and he retained significant good will from his days as governor. Sure, it's Nebraska, but other red-state GOP senators and candidates aren't faring nearly as well this year.

 19 Kansas Pat Roberts (R) 19

There was something of a Jim Slattery bubble in the early summer, and some wondered if this race could actually develop. But Pat Roberts ran a smart mix of early positive and negative ads and has successfully put this race away.

 20 South Carolina Lindsey Graham (R) 20

Graham would probably have won re-election in any circumstance, but if Barack Obama ends up losing S.C. by single digits it will raise the question of what might have been had the DSCC recruited a genuine challenger here.



Interactive Maps

Find county-by-county election results from presidential primary contests across the country.


Special Elections

Six districts are holding contests before November. See the 2008 Special Elections page for a complete rundown.


Poll Track

For the latest polling analysis, read NationalJournal.com's Poll Track.


Caucuses and Primaries

View primary returns for each state in the race to capture the Democratic and Republican nomination for president.


Previous Coverage

Subscriber-only content 2006 Senate Races
Subscriber-only content 2004 Senate Races
Subscriber-only content 2002 Senate Races
Subscriber-only content 2000 Senate Races
Search
Advanced Search
Subscriber-only content Denotes subscriber-only content

Blogs

Advertisement